"To be, or not be, that is the question-". For
some reason, we can all quote it. But what does this famous word even mean?
Hamlet, even though alone, starts to express his thoughts on how he feels about
the pain that life bring and the fear of uncertainty death. But at this point as
reader, you start to wonder if Hamlet has really gone crazy with all the tragedy
that has happens to him or if he’s still faking it.
Olivier's version takes place on top of the rock I believe,
near the water. This adds the perspective that Hamlet’s really trying to
reflect. Also, the fogginess that consumes
the air certainly reflects Hamlet's state of mind. Olivier’s consent close ups
to Hamlet’s forehead shows that these are his thoughts and not just a speech he
is giving like that in the Ghost scene. The Hamlet in this version though seems
more half asleep than that of being depressed. That said, I did not like Olivier's
version. It all seemed to dull to me. I felt like the scene could have been better.
Branaugh's version takes
place in a royal castle with Hamlet looking at him in the mirror, as if looking
in his own eyes for answers. It’s a battle that everyone hates to face, you vs.
yourself; cause you lose either way in the end. Another thing Branaugh's adds
to his version is that Hamlet is being spied on by the men, which goes to show
you that Hamlet is always being watched even when he wants to have time for his
own private thoughts. Branaugh's version is still my favorite once again. While
Hamlet gives his speech not only is there a sound track in the background that adds
some eeriness to the scene, but Hamlet’s sort-of whisper creates this attention
grader to the end.
Zeffirelli's version
was an emotional one. It takes place below the castle where the dead people
are. In this version the actor that portrays Hamlet did an amazing job showing
the pain and struggle that Hamlet was going through. Not only did the actor show
this with his eyes well, but with his body language throughout the scene and
his tone of voice. I think it’s inserting that Zeffirelli’s choose the setting
he did considering Hamlet is completing death.
Of all versions, Zeffirelli’s version displays the sanest Hamlet. This
only version where Hamlet knows suicide cannot be an answer.
No comments:
Post a Comment